Huberman Lab Daily Notes

Independent video index & transcripts

← All transcripts

WHEN TO *NOT* TRUST YOUR THOUGHTS

Watch the original on YouTube ↗

During my recent podcast discussion with @RossEdgley about motivation and how to access it using many mindsets — not just one, we arrived at the topic of circadian (cyclical) influences on mindset. The major takeaway of that portion of podcast is this: the longer you have been awake and in particular when you are awake between the hours of 2 AM and 5 AM (this is assuming you are diurnal) your forebrain is not very good at regulating the aspects of your brain controlling emotionality, rationality, and strategic decision-making. A different way to put this: you are seriously brain impaired during those hours. Again, if you’re nocturnal because you work the night shift this is not the case for that 2 AM to 5 AM stretch but it is true for most people who follow a sleep-wake schedule of asleep sometime between 9pm and 12midnight and wake up 5-8am. So rather than despair about the thoughts that you have if you wake up in the middle of the night or worse— rather than making important decisions on the basis of those thoughts, understand that if you wait 4 to 6 hours (and ideally get some more sleep!) you’ll be significantly sharper, physically stronger and significantly more durable in both mind and body… … and therefore able to make far better decisions. This might seem like simple advice. Or even common sense. But most people don’t realize that their brain just doesn’t function well at those hours, and therefore trusting your thoughts in those hours is not a good idea. Unless you have to in an emergency, of course. The brain is a wonderful organ, but just like many aspects of our biology, not all of its features are adaptive. I thought they come to you when you wake in the middle of the night our altered because of circadian mechanisms. Listen to your thoughts accordingly. Lend weight to them accordingly. Make decisions on the basis of them accordingly. And speaking of thoughts, let me know yours about this topic, whatever they may be. Put them in the comments section below. Thank you for your interest in science! Disclaimer & Disclosures: https://www.hubermanlab.com/disclaimer

AI Summary

English

Overview

The speaker describes a strategy for handling bleak or hopeless thoughts: do not trust negative conclusions that arise during vulnerable periods, especially between 2 and 5 a.m. Difficult mental states can feel permanent, but meaning, logic, and positive emotions often return.

Key ideas

- The speaker follows a personal rule: “don’t believe” thoughts that occur between 2 and 5 a.m., when the mind may present an especially distorted or pessimistic view. - Reaching a “what’s the point?” moment—whether during a physical, cognitive, or emotional challenge—can teach an important lesson. - If a person continues through that moment, they may experience their sense of purpose, rational perspective, and positive emotions returning. - The brain can mistakenly assume that the present state will continue forever. Experiencing recovery firsthand demonstrates that hopelessness can be temporary.

Practical takeaways

- Treat late-night despair or pessimism as a passing mental state rather than a reliable judgment. - Avoid making sweeping conclusions about life while in an acutely negative state. - Remember previous occasions when meaning and positive emotions returned after seeming absent. - When safely possible, allow temporary discomfort to pass before deciding that an effort or situation is pointless.

Caveats and limits

- This is a personal psychological rule and reflection, not a clinical protocol or evidence-based treatment presented with supporting research. - The speaker does not claim that every difficult situation should be endured indefinitely or that all negative thoughts are false. - No specific guidance is given for emergencies, persistent hopelessness, sleep problems, or mental-health crises.

中文翻译

概述

演讲者描述了一种应对阴郁或绝望想法的策略:不要相信在脆弱时段产生的负面结论,尤其是在凌晨2点至5点之间。艰难的心理状态可能让人感觉会永远持续,但意义感、逻辑思维和积极情绪往往会重新出现。

核心观点

- 演讲者遵循一条个人规则:对于凌晨2点至5点之间出现的想法,“不要相信”,因为此时大脑呈现的看法可能格外扭曲或悲观。 - 到达“这样做有什么意义?”的时刻——无论是在身体、认知还是情绪挑战中——都可能让人学到重要的一课。 - 如果一个人继续挺过那个时刻,其目的感、理性视角和积极情绪可能会重新出现。 - 大脑可能会错误地认为当前状态将永远持续下去。亲身经历恢复过程可以证明,绝望可能只是暂时的。

实际要点

- 将深夜的绝望或悲观视为一种会过去的心理状态,而不是可靠的判断。 - 在处于极度消极的状态时,避免对人生作出笼统的结论。 - 回想以往那些意义感和积极情绪在看似消失后又重新出现的时刻。 - 在确保安全的情况下,先让暂时的不适过去,再判断某项努力或某种处境是否毫无意义。

注意事项与局限

- 这是一条个人心理规则和反思,并非临床方案,也不是有支持性研究依据的循证治疗。 - 演讲者并未声称每一种艰难处境都应该无限期忍受,也未声称所有负面想法都是错误的。 - 对于紧急情况、持续的绝望、睡眠问题或心理健康危机,演讲者没有提供具体指导。

Full transcript

don't believe any of your thoughts that occur between 2 and 5 a.m. is when I tell myself all the time, just don't believe it. I don't believe anything my brain tells me between 2 and 5 a.m. And I think they also should have told us that one of the great reasons to get to a point with something, anything, physical, cognitive, emotional, etc., where you feel like what's the point, is so that you can experience the point coming back into your mind and you realize, oh, there are going to be moments in life where I just think like, what's the point? But there will be this moment ahead of it that the logic of it, the positive emotions associated come back. And then you realize the brain tricks itself into thinking that what's happening right now is going to go on forever.